So, I’ve agonized for the hour since I’ve become aware of this individual joining the Discord server for the new Silent Heaven game that has been created with a very specific eye toward and much labor put into being a safe space for players, but I don’t want to sully the advertisement thread or development thread with this issue, because it shines no ‘enlightenment’ on anything specific to the game, and also likely needs to be a bigger discussion contextually speaking than just one game.
An individual that has played another game for a couple of years was recently outted as being underage. The response - or lack thereof - of that game’s administration has become a bit of a sticking point for several people involved with that game on various levels, including some really long-term players and it seems quite a few people from said game have hopped on to enjoy the launch of the Silent Heaven game (I hope they’re all enjoying it as much as I am, too). The playerbase of the older, existing game was informed that some rules are just unenforceable, and that encouraging players to try to enforce them for and between themselves would just foster an atmosphere of distrust and possible exploitation/extortion which is - a take, I suppose. The fact that the whispers have it that this player also sought out, if not outright engaged in, sexual activity in the game with people who had no idea they were, for all intents and purposes, a child, is something I find very alarming and feel also needs some sort of discussion.
I’ve opened this thread to shine light on the fact that that player is now present in the Discord for the Silent Heaven game and to express that at least one of the other players, myself, has a real issue with this. I’d like to hope others will, too, but I’m only speaking for myself here, as somewhat of a keen player of these games but also as someone currently slowly working their way through building a game themself, with a real interest in how @Jumpscare has managed to pull together mechanics and policy to create a place everybody can feel welcome and not be attacked or exploited in an OOC fashion and I’m really loving what I see.
I realize that actually policing age is difficult, if not completely impossible but I think it bears some discussion as to what can or should be done if administration of a game that incorporates adult themes (violence, sex, etc) in its very theme and setting finds out they have underaged players. I also realize that many of the people who were and are members of the communities surrounding these games were under the age of consent themselves when they first began to engage in text-based multiplayer interactive writing games, though I didn’t discover them until I was in my twenties and I think the context of then and now bears some discussion, as well.
Basically, with the recent (welcomed, on my part) emphasis on consent and honesty within these games, enforced to varying degrees through both policies and mechanics, I’m not at all sure how to handle, as a player or future administrator, the possible presence of children in the playerbases I’m also present in, and how to fairly judge how I feel about the violation of boundaries and safety I feel goes on when these kids, with their natural curiosity and lack of understanding of the possible consequences of their behaviors both for themselves and others, lie in order to play these games and get the sorts of interactions they want while playing them.
I hope I managed to raise this topic in a way respectful to both the adult players and possible underaged players who might read it, and with a minimum of accusatory tone, but I’m having some issues with this since it became so suddenly important and I’d like to see the input a community of this nature, with people participating across various game types and genres, has that might help.
At this point, I don’t really want to take the chance of playing and exposing someone else’s kid (I’m a parent myself) to these themes, because I’d be unhappy if I found out my kids were. While I understand this particular individual is going to be of age very soon, it still doesn’t sit well with me that they’ve lied and basically tricked people into activities that would, had they known, violate those other players’ ethical and consent boundaries. At the same time, I don’t just want to quit the hobby wholesale because of the chance of those things happening or completely remove myself from certain games due to their subjects, because I feel like it would be an unfair imposition on me - or any other player feeling the same way - to have to quit games to avoid the issue.
So, that’s where I’m stuck, and I’ve chosen to toss this out to everybody else, hopefully to have a vibrant and respectful discussion about. Thanks in advance.